Harrington Movers

Newark vs. New York 🏆 | Top Pros & Cons: Is NYC or Newark NJ Living Best for You?

Choosing between Newark vs. New York City for your next move presents a unique dilemma. The two cities are separated by the Hudson River and each offers their own unique advantages. New York City is bustling with urban energy, offering a bustling metropolis filled with cultural landmarks and major career opportunities. On the other hand, Newark, New Jersey, often overlooked but highly underrated, boasts a rich history, a growing arts scene, and affordable living costs. Let’s dive into the key factors such as housing, commute, attractions, and career prospects to help you navigate this difficult decision. 

Newark NJ to New York City NY Distance

How far is Newark from New York? It is 11.1 miles from Newark NJ to New York NY. Because of traffic, it typically takes about an hour to drive between the two cities. Alternatively, it will only take you about 20 minutes via public transportation from Newark Penn Station.

Pros and Cons of Living in Newark vs. New York

There are positives and negatives to both cities. These are the pros and cons of New York vs. Newark.

Living in New York Pros

New York City offers a wide range of benefits that attract millions of residents to the city every year. Firstly, the city is a melting pot of cultures, providing endless opportunities to explore different cuisines, arts, and traditions. Additionally, the city is home to some of the world’s most iconic landmarks, such as Times Square, Central Park, and Broadway, which adds to the city’s allure. 

New York also has a thriving job market, with several industries to choose from. You can find a job in anything from finance and fashion to technology and entertainment. Also, the city’s extensive public transportation system allows for easy navigation, and you do not need to own a car when living in the area. 

Living in New York Cons

Living in New York also comes with its fair share of cons, mostly centered around the high cost of living. Housing and rent prices are notoriously steep, with rent consuming a large portion of residents’ incomes, especially in some of the more desirable neighborhoods. The hustle and bustle of the fast-paced city life can also be overwhelming for some. Also, the city’s crowded streets and limited green spaces can make it challenging to find quiet moments amidst the chaos of the urban setting.

Living in Newark Pros

One of the primary advantages of living in Newark is that it is much more affordable compared to the neighboring New York City. Housing prices in Newark are generally lower, making it more accessible for both renters and homebuyers. Also, recent revitalization efforts have led to the creation of new businesses, restaurants, and entertainment venues, adding to the city’s appeal as an up-and-coming urban area. Newark may also feel less chaotic than New York as the city is typically not as busy or frequented by tourists.

Living in Newark Cons

Newark also has a few drawbacks for you to consider. Crime rates in Newark have historically been higher than the national average; however, significant efforts have been made in recent years to improve public safety. Also, Newark does not have as extensive of a public transportation system as New York City, so it may pose challenges for those who rely on alternative modes of transportation.

Comparisons of New York vs. Newark

If you are stuck deciding between New York vs. Newark, then it is important to consider the opportunities and obstacles in both cities. Let’s take a look at the ins and outs of both areas.

Newark vs. New York Demographics

When comparing New York vs. Newark, it is important to consider the difference in population. Newark has a population of 307,220, while New York City has a population of a staggering 8.46 million people.

The Cost of Living in Newark vs. New York

Is New Jersey cheaper than New York? Newark is significantly more affordable than New York. New York is one of the most expensive cities in the northeastern United States, with a Cost of Living Index of 255. This means that living in New York City is 155% more expensive than the national average of 100. The Cost of Living Index in Newark is 123.8, making it 23.8% more expensive than the national average but 131.2% more affordable than New York City.

The home and rent prices of both cities contribute greatly to the gap in the cost of living. According to Redfin, the median home price in New York City is $800,000, compared to $505,000 in Newark. According to RentCafe, the average rent in New York is $4,768 per month, whereas Newark sees an average rent price of only $1,507.

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by BOND New York Real Estate (@bondnewyorkrealestate)

Although it is generally more expensive to live in New York City, it is important to note that New Jersey has some of the highest rates for property taxes in the country, whereas New York doesn't even make the top 10.

New York vs. Newark Crime Rates

When looking at the highlights and challenges of New York vs. Newark, it is important to consider the crime rates in each area. Here's a quick overview of each city's overall, violent, and property crime rates.

New York Crime:

  • Overall crime rate: 2,136 crimes per 100,000 people (9% lower than national average)
  • Violent crime rate: 578 crimes per 100,000 people (49.1% higher than national average)
  • Property crime rate: 1,558 crimes per 100,000 people (20.4% lower than national average)

Newark Crime:

  • Overall crime rate: 2,147 crimes per 100,000 people (8.5% lower than national average)
  • Violent crime rate: 529 crimes per 100,000 people (36.4% higher than national average)
  • Property crime rate: 1,618 crimes per 100,000 people (17.4% lower than national average)

Based on the numbers above, you can see that both cities have similar levels of crime (and both have an overall crime rate that is less than the national average). Naturally, large cities will have crime numbers that are on the higher side; however, most of the crime in both New York and Newark is located in a few select areas where nightlife and gang activity is higher.

Things to Do in Newark vs. New York

There are several fun things to do in both cities, however, New York City is known for its amazing attractions. Whether you are watching a show at Madison Square Garden, checking out a Brooklyn Nets game at the Barclays Center, admiring sculptures at the Metropolitan Museum of Art, or strolling around Times Square, there is something for everyone in New York City. You can also enjoy a bit of nature at places like Central Park and Bryant Park.

View this post on Instagram


A post shared by Big Bootie Land (@bigbootieland)

Although Newark is not always as exciting as New York City, you will still find several fun things to do in the area. Newark has its own fair share of museums, such as the Newark Museum of Art and The New Jersey Historical Society. You'll also find several fun natural attractions in the area, like Branch Brook Park and Military Park. Also, if you ever want to head into NYC to enjoy some of the big-city attractions, you are only a train ride away. 

View this post on Instagram


A post shared by Military Park (@militaryparknwk)

Schools in New York vs. Newark

Both New York and Newark have wonderful school systems. New York is served by New York City Public Schools, which contains over 1.1 million students across 1,800 schools. Newark, on the other hand, is served by a smaller system. Newark Public Schools serves just over 40,000 students across 63 schools.

When it comes to higher education, you will find more options in New York. New York is home to colleges such as New York University and Columbia University, which are some of the most widely recognized educational institutions in the country. However, on the other side of the Hudson River in Newark, you will find wonderful colleges such as Rutgers University and the New Jersey Institute of Technology. 

View this post on Instagram


A post shared by Rutgers University (@rutgersu)

Traffic in Newark vs. New York

According to a recent report from CNBC, New York has the worst traffic out of any city in the country. Driving in New York can be incredibly difficult, especially in busy parts of Manhattan and Brooklyn. This is why most people commute by either walking or public transportation. That being said, the public transport system in NYC is superior to the system in New Jersey. There are dozens of stops around the city, allowing you to get anywhere with trains from Queens, to Staten Island, to Upstate New York.

View this post on Instagram


A post shared by NYC DOT (@nyc_dot)

On the other hand, Newark is a better place to live for those who own a vehicle. The streets are far less crowded, making for far less time stuck in traffic. However, you can still easily commute to New York City and the rest of New York State by car via the Lincoln Tunnel or by public transport via Newark Penn Station. Although not as extensive as New York's system, Newark has a decent bus and train system that can connect you to other areas of New Jersey, such as Jersey City and Hoboken.

Additionally, both cities provide you with easy access to an airport. Newark Liberty International Airport, John F Kennedy International Airport, and LaGuardia Airport are all easily accessible when living in either city.

Economy in New York vs. Newark

Are you thinking about getting a job after moving to the area? Both cities have thriving economies, although you may find more options in New York. NYC encompasses the largest municipal and regional economy in the United States, and the city's gross metropolitan product was $2.1 trillion in 2022. NYC thrives in several different industries, including finance, real estate, and health care.

Although not as big as New York's economy, Newark still has plenty of employment opportunities to choose from. More than 100,000 people commute to Newark each workday, making it the largest employment center in New Jersey. Some of the top employers in Newark include Amazon, Newark Liberty International Airport, and ADP.

According to PayScale, the average salary in New York City is $90,000, while the average salary in Newark is $81,000.

Newark vs. New York: Where Are You Moving? 

Now that you have explored all of the pros and cons of living in Newark vs. New York, where will you be making your move? If you have decided to call Newark home, then get in touch with Harrington Moving & Storage. Our experienced Newark movers will get you settled into your new house in no time. Give our reliable team a call today at 973-313-2246 to discuss your move and get started with a free estimate.

Harrington Movers
As one of the leaders in the New Jersey and New York moving and storage industry, we strive to ensure the satisfaction of our customers. Our goal is to move, or store, your things efficiently and effectively with the utmost professionalism. In fact, Harrington Moving & Storage has been one of the top movers in the New Jersey moving and storage industry since 1996.
Read more by Harrington Movers


Search by Category

Search For more helpful Resources


Paterson NJ Crime Rate [2024] 👮‍♂️ | Is Paterson NJ Safe?

Are you thinking about moving to Paterson NJ? It’s one of the closest large cities in NJ close to NYC […]
Read more >

Living In Elizabeth NJ Ultimate Guide 🏙️ | Why You’ll Love Moving to Elizabeth, New Jersey!

There's lots to love about living in Elizabeth NJ. Incorporated in 1855, the city's rich history, from the Revolutionary War […]
Read more >

Living in Jersey City 🏬 | What to Know Before Moving to Jersey City NJ

Are you considering a move to the vibrant city of Jersey City? Jersey City is situated along the Hudson River […]
Read more >

New Jersey Cities Close to NYC | 🌆 Top Cities in New Jersey Closest to NYC

New Jersey's quite the place to live! US News ranks New Jersey in the top ten states for public safety, […]
Read more >

See What Our Clients Are Saying!

Harrington Moving & Storage 
4.7 Stars out of 5 Out of 272 Reviews


© 2013 - 2024 Harrington Movers® | Privacy Policy | Sitemap